Click GM name to see entire roster so far
| Ed 2 (AL) 0 | Chris 3 (NL) 1 | Ed 1 (NL) -1 | Jim 4 (AL) 2 | Pat 4 (NL) 0 | Pat 2 (AL) -1 | Chris 4 (AL) 0 | Jim 2 (AL) 3 | Chris 1 (AL) 0 | Pat 1 (AL) 0 | Jim 1 (NL) 3 | Chris 2 (NL) 2 | Ed 3 (AL) 0 | Pat 3 (NL) 1 | Ed 4 (NL) 0 | Jim 3 (NL) 3 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Mark McGwire Ed 2 (AL) | Greg Maddux Chris 3 (NL) | Rafael Palmeiro Ed 1 (NL) | Fred McGriff Jim 4 (AL) | Barry Larkin Pat 4 (NL) | Ellis Burks Pat 2 (AL) | Kevin Seitzer Chris 4 (AL) | Mike Greenwell Jim 2 (AL) | Matt Nokes Chris 1 (AL) | Mike Stanley Pat 1 (AL) | David Cone Jim 1 (NL) | Tom Glavine Chris 2 (NL) | Bo Jackson Ed 3 (AL) | Ken Caminiti Pat 3 (NL) | Matt Williams Ed 4 (NL) | Joe Magrane Jim 3 (NL) |
| 2 | Chris James Jim 3 (NL) | Dave Magadan Ed 4 (NL) | John Smiley Pat 3 (NL) | B.J. Surhoff Ed 3 (AL) | Jose Oquendo Chris 2 (NL) | Benito Santiago Jim 1 (NL) | Mike Henneman Pat 1 (AL) | Devon White Chris 1 (AL) | Terry Steinbach Jim 2 (AL) | Mickey Brantley Chris 4 (AL) | Geno Petralli Pat 2 (AL) | Randy Myers Pat 4 (NL) | Dewayne Buice Jim 4 (AL) | Mike Jackson Ed 1 (NL) | Manny Trillo Chris 3 (NL) | Jerry Gleaton Ed 2 (AL) |
| 3 | Doug Jones Ed 2 (AL) | Alvin Hall Chris 3 (NL) | Terry Leach Ed 1 (NL) | Scott Bradley Jim 4 (AL) | Shane Mack Pat 4 (NL) | Jerry Reed Pat 2 (AL) | Dave Valle Chris 4 (AL) | Chris Bosio Jim 2 (AL) | Bobby Thigpen Chris 1 (AL) | Mark Williamson Pat 1 (AL) | Shawn Hillegas Jim 1 (NL) | Mike Dunne Chris 2 (NL) | Kelly Gruber Ed 3 (AL) | Atlee Hammaker Pat 3 (NL) | Steve Trout Ed 4 (NL) | Jeff Parrett Jim 3 (NL) |
| 4 | Gerald Young Jim 3 (NL) | Charlie Puleo Ed 4 (NL) | Eric Nolte Pat 3 (NL) | Bill Wegman Ed 3 (AL) | Bob Forsch Chris 2 (NL) | Tracy Jones Jim 1 (NL) | Dave LaPoint Pat 1 (AL) | Rich Dotson Chris 1 (AL) | John Davis Jim 2 (AL) | Bill Wilkinson Chris 4 (AL) | Bill Long Pat 2 (AL) | John Mitchell Pat 4 (NL) | Todd Benzinger Jim 4 (AL) | Les Lancaster Ed 1 (NL) | Ted Simmons Chris 3 (NL) | Dale Mohorcic Ed 2 (AL) |
| 5 | - | Dave Martinez Chris 3 (NL) | - | Ron Guidry Jim 4 (AL) | Jamie Moyer Pat 4 (NL) | Lee Guetterman Pat 2 (AL) | - | Willie Fraser Jim 2 (AL) | John Farrell Chris 1 (AL) | Jerry Browne Pat 1 (AL) | Keith Comstock Jim 1 (NL) | Luis Aguayo Chris 2 (NL) | Luis Polonia Ed 3 (AL) | Chris Speier Pat 3 (NL) | Matt Young Ed 4 (NL) | - |
| 6 | - | Jim Acker Ed 4 (NL) | Jimmy Jones Pat 3 (NL) | Chuck Crim Ed 3 (AL) | Bill Landrum Chris 2 (NL) | Casey Candaele Jim 1 (NL) | Dave Bergman Pat 1 (AL) | Edwin Nunez Chris 1 (AL) | Charles Hudson Jim 2 (AL) | - | John Habyan Pat 2 (AL) | Dickie Noles Pat 4 (NL) | - | - | Barry Jones Chris 3 (NL) | Al Pedrique Pat 4 (NL) |
| 7 | Walt Terrell Pat 2 (AL) | Jeff M. Robinson Jim 2 (AL) | Tommy Hinzo Chris 1 (AL) | Mike Flanagan Pat 1 (AL) | Rick Schu Chris 2 (NL) | Jose Guzman Ed 3 (AL) | Juan Castillo Pat 1 (AL) | Mark Huismann Pat 1 (AL) | Juan Nieves Pat 1 (AL) | Oddibe McDowell Pat 2 (AL) | Doug DeCinces Pat 2 (AL) | Don Gordon Pat 2 (AL) | Jeff Musselman Pat 2 (AL) | Junior Ortiz Pat 3 (NL) | Brian Holton Pat 3 (NL) | Randy St.Claire Pat 3 (NL) |
| 8 | Mike Fitzgerald Pat 4 (NL) | Bob Melvin Pat 4 (NL) | Chris Brown Pat 4 (NL) |