| RYAN SCH | JIM BURWITZ | DAVE | JAY | STEVE | ED | CRAIG | BRAD | CHRIS | HANK | ||
| 1 | Travis Hafner | Carlos Beltran | James Shields | Aroldis Chapman | Victor Martinez | Lance Berkman | Jon Lester | Jeremy Hellickson | Ryan Doumit | Hunter Pence | 1 |
| 2 | Shaun Marcum | Logan Morrison | Neftali Feliz | Jhoulys Chacin | David Ortiz | Matt Joyce | Carlos Pena | Craig Kimbrel | Adam Jones | Elvis Andrus | 2 |
| 3 | Yadier Molina | Ben Zobrist | Matt Garza | Justin Morneau | Andre Ethier | Jhonny Peralta | Aramis Ramirez | Chase Utley | Adam Dunn | Jose Valverde | 3 |
| 4 | Jason Motte | Ian Kinsler | Johnny Cueto | David Wright | Mike Adams | Carlos Quentin | Jonny Venters | Javier Vazquez | Tim Stauffer | Heath Bell | 4 |
| 5 | Danny Valencia | Ryan Howard | Neil Walker | Ramon Hernandez | Joel Peralta | Daniel Bard | Koji Uehara | Alex Gordon | Nick Swisher | Jonathan Papelbon | 5 |
| 6 | Joaquin Benoit | Scott Baker | Chris Carpenter | Jayson Werth | Scott Downs | David Hernandez | Sergio Romo | Jay Bruce | Dan Uggla | Lance Lynn | 6 |
| 7 | James Loney | Ervin Santana | Drew Storen | Shin Soo Choo | Hole Camels | Daniel Hudson | Marco Scutaro | Zack Grienke | Brendan Boesch | Drew Pomeranz | 7 |
| 8 | Jamey Carroll | Yovani Gallardo | Pedro Alvarez | Adam Wainwright | Adrian Beltre | Mat Latos | Nyjer Morgan | Josh Beckett | Julio Teheran | Carlos Lee | 8 |
| FRANCHISE | David Price | Justin Upton | Albert Pujols | Bryce Harper | Joey Votto | Dustin Ackley | Jacob Ellsbury | Jose Reyes | Eric Hosmer | Justin Verlander | FRANCHISE |
| FRANCHISE | Brandon Phillips | Alex Avila | Matt Holliday | Brett Lawrie | Troy Tulowitski | Carlos Santana | Mark Teixeira | Matt Kemp | Jason Heyward | Felix Hernandez | FRANCHISE |
| FRANCHISE | Michael Morse | Starling Castro | Hanley Ramirez | Buster Posey | Ian Kennedy | Stephen Strasburg | Michael Pineda | Adrian Gonzalez | Mike Trout | Evan Longoria | FRANCHISE |
| RYAN SCH | JIM BURWITZ | DAVE | JAY | STEVE | ED | CRAIG | BRAD | CHRIS | HANK | ||
| SHANE | JASON A | JASON V | DARREN | ADAM | RYAN SUL | JIMMY-MAN | PAT | MATT | JOE | ||
| 1 | Gavin Floyd | Ivan Nova | Dan Haren | Josh Hamilton | Corey Hart | Todd Helton | Chris Young | Ryan Zimmerman | Domonic Brown | Wilson Betemit | 1 |
| 2 | Billy Butler | David Robertson | Wandy Rodriguez | Andrew McCutchen | Pedro Sandoval | Josh Johnson | JJ Putz | Miguel Montero | Blake Dewitt | Edwin Encarnacion | 2 |
| 3 | Carlos Marmol | Russell Martin | Clay Buchholz | Rickie Weeks | Melky Cabrera | Brian Wilson | G. Parra | Doug Fister | Derek Jeter | JJ Hardy | 3 |
| 4 | Daniel Murphy | Joel Pineiro | Carl Crawford | Michael Young | Freddie Freeman | Chris Sale | Martin Prado | Mark Reynolds | Dee Gordon | Chipper Jones | 4 |
| 5 | Sergio Santos | Jorge Posada | Torii Hunter? | Gio Gonzalez | Beachy | Shane Victorino | CJ Wilson | Drew Stubbs | Jesus Montero | Alfonso Soriano | 5 |
| 6 | Jordan Zimmermann | David Aardsma | Colby Rasmus | Max Scherzer | Mariano Rivera | Alexei Ramirez | Kyle Farnsworth | Brett Anderson | Grant Balfour | Nick Hundley | 6 |
| 7 | Kevin Youkilis | Kerry Wood | Casey Kotchman | Sean Marshall | Joel Hanrahan | Chase Headley | Josh Willingham | Edward Mujica | Carlos Villanueva | Chris Iannetta | 7 |
| 8 | Nelson Cruz | Ryan Theriot | Asdrubal Cabrera | Anibal Sanchez | Howie Kendrick | Danny Espinoza | Hiroki Kuroda | Ryan Madson | Kelly Shoppach | Ramon Ramirez | 8 |
| FRANCHISE | Tommy Hanson | Alex Rodriguez | Clayton Kershaw | Curtis Granderson | Tim Hudson | Ryan Braun | Roy Halladay | Jose Bautista | Carlos Gonzalez | CC Sabathia | FRANCHISE |
| FRANCHISE | Justin Masterson | Cliff Lee | Joe Mauer | Mike Stanton | Billy McCann | Ricky Romero | Mike Napoli | Robinson Cano | Matt Wieters | Jered Weaver | FRANCHISE |
| FRANCHISE | John Axford | Madison Bumgarner | Dustin Pedroia | Miguel Cabrera | Matt Cain | Paul Konerko | Tim Lincecum | Prince Fielder | Nick Markakis | Ubaldo Jimenez | FRANCHISE |
| SHANE | JASON A | JASON V | DARREN | ADAM | RYAN SUL | JIMMY-MAN | PAT | MATT | JOE | ||